5 Medications or Supplements That Made Me More Depressed


healthtap.comThe more medications and supplements I try in an effort to minimize my symptoms of depression and anxiety, the more I realize that every editable item you place in your mouth has a risk associated with it. Even the natural ones that are supposedly made from cats’ claws, wild yams, or some organic plant. Moreover, YOU need to read about its potential side effects and inform yourself before you place the thing on your tongue, because chances are your doctor won’t be well-versed on all the strange reactions it could cause.

I write this article not to scare you, but out of responsibility. Had a few people not written online about their experience with the hormone supplement progesterone, I’m not sure I would be here to inform you about my negative responses to a few medications and supplements I’ve tried in the last ten years. Of course, some of these may do wonders for you, as some of the drugs that I have taken for years, like Lithium, were not tolerated by friends of mine. Each of us is so different with unique biochemistries. At any rate, here are a few medications and supplements that made my symptoms worse.

1. Natural progesterone

After some test results showed that I was low on the steroid hormone progesterone, a functional doctor I’ve been working with prescribed 30 mg. (during days 5 to 15 of my menstrual cycle) and then 60 mg. (during days 16 to 25 of my menstrual cycle) of NATURAL progesterone (the synthetic progesterones, like Provera or medroxyprogesterone, can cause even worse side effects). I didn’t notice much change the first ten days; however, by the time I graduated to 60 mg. I was having intense, suicidal thoughts. For the eight days that I took the full dose, all I could think about were strategies on how to successfully exit this world. One morning I did a long, open-water swim with some very competitive athletes. They were way ahead, so I was swimming alone in choppy water with lots of boat traffic. Instead of panicking, I thought, “If I can just swim toward the traffic, chances are pretty good that I would get hit by a boat.” Just then I remembered that a friend of mine had the same reaction when she used progesterone cream a few years back. She told me the day after she rubbed it all over her chest she wanted to jump off the Bay Bridge. She would have if she’d had a car to get there. I made it out of the bay alive and researched progesterone when I got home. I found out that approximately 19 percent of folks who take natural progesterone capsules experience depression, and suicidal ideation occurs in about 5 percent of people, or maybe everyone living by the Bay Bridge?

2. Wellbutrin (Bupropion)

Bupropion is a dopamine reuptake inhibitor that operates a little differently than selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) like Prozac and Zoloft. I really wanted this drug to work because it’s one of the few without sexual or weight side-effect. However, by about the second day on this drug, I felt as though I were existing in a black prison, looking out through the jail cell to a world that I couldn’t understand. I remember watching a ceremony at the Naval Academy and thought to myself, “How does everyone have the strength to get up each morning and get dressed for this? How can a person have the mental capability to study for a test or teach a course? Why doesn’t everyone commit suicide? Where does everyone find the determination to keep living?” I was suffocating in this dark jail cell. I wanted out of the world in the worst way, and yet I was trapped. I couldn’t eat. My heart raced. I felt nauseous. Tears kept coming. I couldn’t restrain them, not even in front of my kids. It was a similar experience as that described by William Styron in his classic “Darkness Visible.” It was hell.

3. BuSpar (Buspirone)

Buspirone is commonly used to treat anxiety, and it did that. Initially. But then I started to have out-of-body experiences. I couldn’t see dead people or anything, but I would be sitting there having a nice conversation with someone, and then all of a sudden it was like I was witnessing me in that conversation from about 50 feet high. It was scary. It felt like I was tripping out on some magic mushrooms, LSD, or some other psychedelic drug.

4. Lunesta (Eszopiclone)

I was completely desperate to get some shuteye when I started taking this drug. I first tried less risky drugs (Seroquel, Doxepin, Trazedone), but I was still waking up after two or three hours. So I did something against my better judgment and took a medication that has been known be addictive. Ideally its use should be limited to one or two weeks so that your nervous system doesn’t start depending on it. Persons who have histories of substance abuse like I do should think VERY carefully about using it at all. The first few nights were divine. I was sleeping again. But then my body started tolerating it more and more, which meant that the withdrawals were getting more painful—symptoms of anxiety and panic—requiring more of the stuff to quiet my nerves. Even though the drug isn’t a benzodiazepine, it essentially acts like one, and I have had anxiety hangovers with every benzodiazepine (Ativan and Klonopin) I’ve tried.

5. Zyprexa (Olanzapine)

I’m not sure how many milligrams I was on the morning I essentially fell into my bowl of granola at the breakfast table. You know that scene in Shrek when Princess Fiona had turned into an ogre and Donkey finds her, thinking the ogre had eaten the princess? Yeah, well, it was like that in our house. The good news is that I had only gained ten pounds on the drug (in the two weeks I was on it), but my husband was curious if this zombie person who was hanging out with the family had eaten his wife. My psychiatrist at the time, I later learned, was getting some nice kickbacks from the drug’s manufacturer, which is probably why all of his patients (or at least the ones leaving his office when I was there) were well-stocked with Zyprexa samples. Turns out I don’t respond well to any kind of atypical neuroleptic or antipsychotic: Abilify, Geodon, Risperdal, or Seroquel. They make me, for a lack of a better word, psychotic.

Originally published on Sanity Break at Everyday Health.

Image: healthtap.com

Share this:

Therese Borchard
I am a writer and chaplain trying to live a simple life in Annapolis, Maryland.

More about me...




February 23, 2024
November 24, 2023
Everything Is Grace: Cultivating Gratitude From a Greater Altitude
June 11, 2023
Do One Thing Every Day That Scares You
May 20, 2023
Please Let Me Cry
February 16, 2023
Love Being Loving

Related Posts

11 Responses
  1. Isn’t it amazing that after all of this we’re STILL HERE?! I’m a medical marvel me. I could list at least 10 different drugs and/or supplements that made me freak out and I bet you could too! I can’t tell you how relieved I felt after my last meds worked!

  2. Melanie

    This is so helpful! Thank you! I suspected a couple of those meds might me be making me more depressed and not wanting to live.

  3. Shanti

    Psychiatrist have all agreed that hormones increases the symptoms of depression and so do Pharmacies. This is a known fact yet more Pills are being pushed on the consumers with out there knowledge.
    We definitely know that MIRENA and similar drugs increases anxiety, mood swings and mania depression. Why is this still being given? I personally feel this is criminal.

    Young adults who are on birth controls have no idea that the monsters in there head is not creation of bad parents or bad spouses & in laws. It’s the man in the white coat who believes what the pharmaceutical companies tell them.

  4. Bella

    iI just need to add that Wellbutrin and I do NOT mix well at all. Originally my doctor prescribed this to go along with the Effexor XR I am on to attack the weight gain I got with the Effexor. It did help, but then I began getting horrible stomach upset with it. So unfortunately I had to stop it. So far I have not been able to find a drug that will work well for anxiety and NOT cause me weight gain.

  5. Kitty

    I was blown away reading this. I had the exact same experience (no kidding) with Wellbutrin last week. I wanted to try something different and weight gain was also an issue. I was on 150 mg of Venlafaxine ER (generic for Effexor). My doctor told me to take half a pill of the former for one week, then go straight to the Wellbutrin. The first day was ok as I was busy. The second day was a little shaky, but I was exercising so it was fine, or so I thought. By the third day I was falling apart, and by the fourth I was cussing and screaming every time I was alone. I am not a cussing-and-screaming kind of person, really. When I called the office, the doctor was on vacation, so I told them, well, I am going back to the old medication because I can’t do this. Perhaps I needed a longer time to taper. I so appreciate reading your RIGHT-ON descriptions that truly resonate with me! And I love the comments of other kindred spirits here!

  6. Tijdeling

    I’ve tried Wellbutrin. The psychiatrist described it as a ‘kick in the ass’ medicine. It would give me more energy to release my dysthymia. Itgave me extreme headaches and didn’t do anything else. What you’re describing with Wellbutrin is how I feel now. How do people live on? What’s the point really? Why can’t I just go?
    Especially after Robin Williams death, which has greatly affected me, I wonder why so many people have to go through this. I take Prozac, but that doesn’t do much either. Most professionals say… well, on to the next. Like it’s just a thing I have to do. Completely ignoring the hell I’m in. I think we desperatly need to rethink the value of life and be prepared to let go sometimes. But I’m getting off-topic right now. I am extremely jealous of those who benefit from medicine, but we have to remember that there are so many who don’t respond to it.

    1. I know what you mean. It can be infuriating. I have found some peace in Toni Bernhard’s book, “How to Be Sick.” She is very forthright that some people have to live with chronic illnesses their entire lives, and yet they can have meaningful, full lives. It’s a Buddhist perspective that it becoming increasingly more helpful as I fight this illness on a daily basis.

      1. Tijdeling

        Thanks for your response. How do you feel about medication in general? I use some, without great effect and have used a few others in the past. Pills scare me though. I’m so afraid to lose myself. To become someone different. I’ve recently been told I might be undermedicated. A different medicine at a higher dosage might get sugested. I could refuse, but then what. It’s not like refusing cancer treatment where the problem will eventually take care of itself.

        1. To tell you the truth, I’m mixed. Meds, on one hand, saved my life in 2006. However, the more treatment-resistant I become, I realize their limitations, and that you absolutely have to explore other ways of managing the illness. Had this discussion with my doc yesterday. I am always trying to go down. She’s always trying to make me go up. I think it’s just different for everyone, but I definitely don’t think they work miracles as I once did.

  7. Hi Ms. Borchard,

    Why do psychiatrists seem so comfortable relying solely on trial and error to prescribe medications – many of which are potentially extremely dangerous? Is anyone seriously attempting (or even concerned) to develop objective tests to prioritize the best and worst drug regimes for individual patients?